Faxon Firearms vs Superlative Arms: AR-15 brands compared

Faxon Firearms leads in 6 of 6 categories.

Faxon Firearms for receivers and furniture. Superlative Arms for gas blocks.

From tens of thousands of real builds and live prices at 35+ retailers.

Our take

Faxon Firearms is best for:

Faxon Firearms makes its own AR barrels in Ohio, like the Gunner profile, plus bolt carrier groups.

In-house barrels · Lifetime guarantee · ISO 9001 certified · Family owned

  • Close to average prices
  • The more popular pick: in 8% of builds
  • Receivers (Superlative Arms receivers are rarely picked)
  • Furniture (Superlative Arms furniture are rarely picked)

Superlative Arms is best for:

Superlative Arms makes bleed off adjustable gas blocks that vent extra gas out the front instead of choking it off. Handy on a suppressed or short barrel rifle.

Adjustable gas blocks · Bleed-off design · Clamp-on · Suppressor friendly

  • Paying more: about 1.7x the average price
  • Gas blocks, picked 17x as often

Many builders mix them: 27% of Superlative Arms builds add Faxon Firearms, most often the barrel.

Biggest differences

"Picked" is the share of builds with that part that chose each brand.

Faxon FirearmsSuperlative ArmsDifference
Price vs average15% cheaper1.7x averageFaxon Firearms cheaper
Share of builds8%2%Faxon Firearms 4x
Gas blocks picked1.0%18%Superlative Arms 18x
Parts listed675124Faxon Firearms 5x
Retailers carrying159Faxon Firearms 1.7x

Price: Faxon Firearms wins

For the same part, Faxon Firearms parts run 15% cheaper than average and Superlative Arms parts run 1.7x the average price.

Builder favorite: Faxon Firearms wins

Faxon Firearms is in 8% of builds and Superlative Arms is in 2% of builds.

Why Faxon Firearms: Every barrel is MPI checked, air gauged and covered by Faxon's Lifetime Guarantee.

Receivers: Faxon Firearms wins

Faxon Firearms upper receivers picked often, Superlative Arms rarely.

Internals: Faxon Firearms wins

Builders pick Superlative Arms gas blocks (17x) more often than Faxon Firearms. Faxon Firearms barrels and bolt carrier groups are picked often, Superlative Arms's rarely.

Why Faxon Firearms: Faxon barrels come in 4150 CMV or 416R stainless, button rifled, with QPQ nitride or PVD finishes.

Furniture: Faxon Firearms wins

Faxon Firearms handguards picked often, Superlative Arms rarely.

Shopper clicks: Faxon Firearms wins

Of recent clicks through to a store for these brands, 83% went to Faxon Firearms and 17% went to Superlative Arms.

The full record

Everything we track for Faxon Firearms vs Superlative Arms, from builds, store listings and daily prices.

Faxon FirearmsSuperlative Arms
Share of builds8%2%
Price tierMid pricedPremium
Parts listed675124
Part types162
Retailers carrying159
In stock now55%70%
Price change, 90 dayson the most picked parts4% lowerFlat
On sale now1 partNone

On sale now

What builders pair with them

Faxon Firearms vs Superlative Arms: questions builders ask

Which should you buy, Faxon Firearms or Superlative Arms?

Faxon Firearms for receivers and furniture. Superlative Arms for gas blocks. Pick Faxon Firearms if you want close to average prices: builders pay 15% cheaper than average. Builders pick its receivers far more often and furniture far more often. Pick Superlative Arms if you don't mind paying more: builders pay 1.7x the average price. Builders pick its gas blocks 17x as often. Or mix them like builders do: 27% of Superlative Arms builds add Faxon Firearms, most often the barrel.

Is Faxon Firearms cheaper than Superlative Arms?

Faxon Firearms. Faxon Firearms 15% cheaper than average, Superlative Arms 1.7x the average price.

Which do more AR-15 builders use, Faxon Firearms or Superlative Arms?

Faxon Firearms. Faxon Firearms is in 3.3x as many builds.

Faxon Firearms or Superlative Arms: which receivers do builders pick?

Faxon Firearms. Faxon Firearms upper receivers picked often, Superlative Arms rarely.

Faxon Firearms or Superlative Arms: which internals do builders pick?

Faxon Firearms. Superlative Arms gas blocks picked 17x as often.

Faxon Firearms or Superlative Arms: which furniture do builders pick?

Faxon Firearms. Faxon Firearms handguards picked often, Superlative Arms rarely.

Can you mix Faxon Firearms and Superlative Arms parts?

Yes. 27% of Superlative Arms builds add Faxon Firearms, most often the barrel.

What is Faxon Firearms known for?

Faxon Firearms makes its own AR barrels in Ohio, like the Gunner profile, plus bolt carrier groups.

What is Superlative Arms known for?

Superlative Arms makes bleed off adjustable gas blocks that vent extra gas out the front instead of choking it off. Handy on a suppressed or short barrel rifle.